by Jonalyn Fincher
Garth Brooks, I’m also thankful for unanswered prayer.
But that does’t stop me from praying.
I agree with Scot McKnight, that praying merely expecting change in me is a cop out.
I pray with clear requests, expecting change in the world.
“God I need your help to find Finn a new babysitter. We need one soon. In order to not feel stressed about it I need to find one this month, so I can interview and give her time with Finn so the transition will be smooth. Make sense?“
To show him that I’m doing my share of the work, I began a sunburst of activity hunting, following up all my leads. With internal pressure building and caretakers turning me down, I am embarrassed to say I actually responded once to a very gracious, “No” with, “Can you pray about it?”
When caretakers didn’t call me back within 24 hours, I fretted. I called them twice a day. One, call her Andrea, I felt would work well, but I kept missing her call backs and would always get her voicemail.
GRRR! “God is this a sign? If so it’s very frustrating because I don’t have any other leads!“
Weeks pass, no answer to my prayer.
One Sunday, our current babysitter, Belinda, who we are losing soon, came over as Dale and I prepared for a Skype session. We’d set this up months ago.
Dressed in Sunday best, Dale and sat down in our living room, pray for clarity and love, cleared our throats, grabbed our notes and we were LIVE. Belinda was outside putting the finishing touches of sunscreen on Finn for a morning walk.
But something wasn’t right. As the screen showed the church in Dallas, the class was walking out right when we were ready to begin.
Groaning internally with frustration, we realized someone had converted the time zone difference backwards. We talked about rescheduling and signed off. That’s unanswered prayer number one: botched speaking opportunity.
Feeling rather let-down, I changed and in a moment of spontaneity ran down the walk to join Belinda and Finn for their walk. I felt like heaven pushed me away from my desk.
I had three hours to get caught up with emails and writing and I chose a walk instead. That’s unanswered prayer number two: I ask for time to get my work done and in this case I threw the time out the window and went on a walk.
I found myself sharing about Andrea and how much I wanted her to sit for us. Belinda was quiet enough that I started digging. Turned out Belinda knew Andrea. They had lived together in Seattle. I didn’t know either lived in Seattle. And I had no idea they knew each other.
Belinda shared a few highly pertinent details, things only a roommate would know. Things that cleared the dark glass of frustration. Stuff that screeched my eager wheels to a halt. Andrea would not be a good fit for Finn.
Unanswered prayer quickly morphed into an answered prayer for the end game: a good caretaker for my son.
I started over. Asked friends and, oh so uncomfortable, just waited. I still pray, “God find someone for us.”
A friend knew someone and asked her. I had to wait five days for the necessary introductions, explanations. Then, got her number.
She called me back the same day.
She’s come to our house, I’ve been to hers. She has lived in this area for years, she’s had three kids. She wants to be part of Finn’s life long term. My heart bubbles with relief when I think of her with Finn.
So I touch base with God.
God, I am grateful you never let me connect with Andrea. I’m sorry for my “GRRRR” attitude on several accounts, the missed calls, the skype event mistake which led me to a walk where you let me glimpse the why. Thank you for this mother who already loves Finn.
I believe prayer changes things, other people, Skype coordinations, meetings, attitudes. I believe prayer opens hearts, closes mouths, stops work, starts rest. When prayer changes me, I believe I’m witnessing a miracle.
Consider how often you want to change something about yourself and find it a Sisyphean task.
I want to change things in me and for years find myself unsuccessful. This is the working out salvation bit that I think God wants for us. He wants to accompany our work with his own. Grace is opposed to our earning, not our effort.
My specific, unanswered prayers have been a highway to transformation. So I still prayer specifically, less discouraged because God’s “No”‘s might mean “Yes” for what I really am looking for.
Photo credit: gregorynsmith.blogspot.com


Jonalyn, thank you for reminding me that God still hears our prayers. I needed to hear this … badly… as we deal with the mystery of Baby A’s seizures. You’d think this long into my walk with the Lord that I’d be so secure in that trust. What a heart check the last six months has been! We are thankful for the work Soulation does. Hugs to you guys.
Tina Marie,
I think seeing someone suffer without being able to explain pushes my trust into uncharted waters, too.
What do you think of the metaphor of trust as a muscle that needs constant maintenance/”gym” work?
Jonalyn-
You have no idea how relevant this is right now in our lives. I see lots of unanswered prayers and my anxiety grows with every day of uncertainty.
This gives me hope.
Randi,
Your walk with God has given me much to thank him for.
Jonalyn,
Love this post! I am a firm believer that prayer changes things. How it works is a mystery to me, but I’ve seen many answers to prayer. One recent example was last week when I had to sell my brother’s car on Craig’s List. I’d never sold a car before or ever really used Craig’s List so I was nervous on multiple levels. I prayed for the process to move quickly and that I wouldn’t have to deal with weird people as Barry would be busy with other things and I’d have to carry the whole load myself. The first guy who emailed me came with his wife and two kids to test drive the car. They were really normal and let me know the next day they wanted the car. The whole transaction was completed in a week. This isn’t one of those major life changing examples, but it shows me that God cares about all manner of things in my life.
A bigger example was praying for a grad program for Barry. This was years of prayer, seeking and searching. Nothing was working out and after a rejection of what we thought would be the perfect program we almost gave up. I decided to pray about it one more time to see if there was anything out there that met our specifications. The next day we found a program. 4 months later he was taking classes.
I don’t pretend to know all of the nuances of prayer and why some get answered and others don’t and how all of that works. But I trust the character of God and that He wants the best for me. I know He wants to move on my behalf and work with me because I’m his friend. There’s also the spiritual warfare piece to all of this that complicates matters too.
All of the times my prayers have been answered grow my faith and help me when things seem quiet. Tine Marie, I know God cares about Baby A and is moving behind the scenes on his behalf. Praying for wisdom for you guys and your family.
Jules,
You’re so right, it is a mystery, when and why some are so beautifully answered and others fall like a wet blanket. But we can know some things about God and prayer.
He doesn’t say “no” to all requests.
He is very personal and detailed with some of his answers, etc.
I think sharing stories of how God’s hand does materialize in our lives builds our understanding into prayer-ology, or at least his kindness and character.
That’s why I enjoyed your stories.
Hooray for smooth sales on craig’s list
Loved this line in your comment: I know He wants to move on my behalf and work with me because I’m his friend.
This was so encouraging. I’m reading and nodding my head, and while my head agrees, my worry pops into my head about our renter who lost her job, and the fact we’ll be without rental income for our house in NW Florida and a feeling of fear about finding a new renter, and the cost a property management company will bring, and these things roll around in my head like so many India rubber balls, refusing to slow down. I wonder can we handle all of the balls – keep them juggling in the air?
Then…about mid-post reading what you were sharing, it occurs to me that duh, sometimes God puts these uncomfortable things in my way to build my faith. All of those balls? He’s not the least bit challenged. Just a few months ago I was constantly amazed at how well God put things together for us to move, and now another hurdle is here, and I realize I am so fickle, partially because this situation was my worst fear, and I reacted internally – viserally – not thinking, already forgetting recent miracles. Do I need constant reassurement or can I just TRUST Him to help me the way He always has? The question is rhetorical, and the answer my head says should be obvious, so why does my stomach still knot up and a nervous feeling sit there just under the surface? I look forward to seeing what happens, meanwhile reminding myself that it’s the faith and prayer muscles I’m building that I can look back on with praise. It will be one of the steps behind me, something to encourage people with when they have their own scary moment, and something to make me just a little more sensitive and humble. We’ll see what happens with the situation and what God does. Meanwhile my abba, father is teaching me more because He loves me and wants me to be just that much closer with just that much stronger faith. This is how your openness blessed me, Jonalyn.
“If patience is worth anything, it must endure to the end of time. And a living faith will last in the midst of the blackest storm. Faith is not something to grasp, it is a state to grow into.” – Mohandas Gandhi
rubber balls bouncing around! Love that picture.
So how has your faith been growing since you wrote the above? Do you have a story for the ages?
I love when God gently reminds us that these times are chances to trust. I love it more when I accept the invite.
Great Gandhi quote, too.
Hi Jonalyn, I just discovered this article and I really liked it. This morning I was reading John 14, where Jesus says, “If you ask for anything in my name, I will do it.” It’s interesting to see that he was doing that here, even though he was not doing it in the way you asked for it to be done.
Nicki,
That is a great point. Glad you discovered this article and liked it. We’ll be re-using this post, with some severe edits for our new book at SoulationPress coming out for Easter called “Long Live the King”.